OUVRAGE : J. Garvey, Nuclear Weapons Counterproliferation: A New Grand Bargain

Catherine MAIA

Nuclear Weapons Counterproliferation: A New Grand Bargain proposes a new legal and institutional framework for counterproliferation of nuclear weapons. Its proposal is designed to remedy the widely acknowledged breakdown of the architecture of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty on which we can no longer rely for global nuclear security. First, Nuclear Weapons Counterproliferation defines the distinctively dangerous character of contemporary nuclear risk and explains why the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty no longer provides a viable foundation for counterproliferation of nuclear weapons. It then sets out the reforms needed in order to limit the radical increase in availability, for rogue governments and terrorists, of nuclear weapons related material and technology. Garvey then proposes a new counterproliferation architecture, to be built on presently available scientific, legal, and institutional resources, which could achieve a critical reduction of nuclear risk and an expanded deterrence. Guiding principles for establishing this new architecture are formulated, including, most importantly, the principal mechanism for implementation, a proposed United Nations Security Council Counterproliferation Resolution applying equally for all states. This book presents what may be our best opportunity to secure a profoundly more effective global nuclear security and counter the world's current course to a catastrophic nuclear detonation.


TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. Introduction A. The Need for a New Counterproliferation Foundation B. The Old Grand Bargain Breakdown i. The Goal of Nuclear Disarmament ii. The Flawed Nexus of Nuclear Disarmament and Nuclear Counterproliferation C. Legitimacy; The Challenge of Asymmetric Possession of Nuclear Weapons II. Futility of Nuclear Risk Management in a Purely Consensual Regime A. Nuclear Terrorism B. State-to-State Nuclear Weapons Risk C. Risk Reduction by Consent III. Security Council Mandate of Universal Standards A. 'Global Legislation' by the United Nations Security Council i. The Security Council as Global Legislator ii. The Legal Debate iii. The Legal Debate Enlightened by Political Realism iv. Counterproliferation as Best Prospect for Security Council Legislation B. Counterproliferation Beyond Current 'Legislation' C.Universal Standards i. Nuclear Security as an Independent International Interest ii. No Classification of States iii. International Administration of Universal Standards IV. Elements of an Effective Counterproliferation Architecture A. Expanding Deterrence; An International Nuclear Forensics Data Bank i. Contemporary Nuclear Forensics Capability ii. Expanded Deterrence iii. The Legal and Institutional Empowerment of Nuclear Forensics B. The Internationalization of Counterproliferation Intelligence i. The Incongruity of National Intelligence Resources and Transnational Nuclear Risk ii. The Imperative for International Institutionalization of Intelligence iii. Feasibility C. Export-Import Control i. The Club that Cannot Counter-Proliferate ii. Institutionalization of Export-Import Controls under Security Council Mandate D. Internationalization of the Nuclear Fuel Cycle E. Interdiction of Nuclear Weapons Related Transport; The Proliferation Security Initiative i. Counterproliferation Designed to be Least Legal; 'An Activity, Not an Organization' ii. Interface of the Proliferation Security Initiative and International Law a. Coastal State Jurisdiction b. High Seas Jurisdiction c. Self-Defense iii. Institutionalization of the Proliferation Security Initiative under Security Council Mandate; Legitimacy and Effectiveness V. Compliance VI. Political Will VII. Conclusion Jack GARVEY, Nuclear Weapons Counterproliferation: A New Grand Bargain, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2013 (256 pp.) Jack Garvey is Professor of Law at the University of San Francisco School of Law, where he is also Chairman of the International Programs Department. Professor Garvey holds degrees at the University of Chicago, Harvard College, Oxford University, and Harvard Law School. Professor Garvey served as law clerk for Judge Hubert L. Will of the U.S. Federal District Court in Chicago and also as legislative assistant and speechwriter for Senator George McGovern, with responsibility for foreign policy positioning of the McGovern campaign for the Presidency of the United States. Professor Garvey practiced international law in San Francisco with the firm of Graham and James.